Impact of a DUI-Related Accident on My Car Insurance: What to Expect

June 28, 2024

Impact of a DUI-Related Accident on My Car Insurance: What to Expect

What is DUI-Driving Under the Influence

Driving Under the Influence (DUI) refers to operating a motor vehicle while impaired by alcohol or drugs to the extent that it affects the driver’s ability to safely operate the vehicle. In many jurisdictions, DUI-Related Accident specifically refers to impairment caused by alcohol consumption above legal limits set by the local laws. It is a serious offense due to the increased risk of accidents and harm to oneself and others on the road. Penalties for DUI can vary widely depending on the jurisdiction and circumstances, but commonly include fines, license suspension or revocation, mandatory education or treatment programs, and in some cases, imprisonment.

If you’re convicted of DUI—commonly referred to as “Driving Under the Influence” (DWI or Driving While Intoxicated)—you’ll inevitably confront various legal challenges, regardless of whether a DUI-related car accident was involved.

Consequently, the impact on your car insurance might not be your primary concern. However, depending on your state of residence and the insurance provider that issued your policy, you could encounter several insurance-related issues. These range from potential policy cancellation to the insurer refusing coverage for any claims regarding personal injury or property damage resulting from your DUI incident. Read further for more detailed information.

Can the Car Insurance Company Deny Coverage After a DUI-Related Accident?

Can the Car Insurance Company Deny Coverage After a DUI?

Yes, car insurance companies can potentially deny coverage after a DUI (Driving Under the Influence) incident. A typical liability car insurance policy covers accidents where the policyholder or another covered party drives negligently, possibly even recklessly depending on policy terms, causing an accident. However, no policy covers accidents resulting from intentional conduct.

  1. Intentional Conduct Argument: Insurers may argue that driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs constitutes intentional misconduct. They contend that by choosing to drink excessively, becoming impaired, and then driving, the individual knowingly put themselves and others at risk. Intentional misconduct is typically excluded from coverage under standard auto insurance policies.
  2. Policy Terms and Conditions: Most auto insurance policies include clauses that exclude coverage for losses or damages resulting from intentional acts. Since DUI is often considered an intentional act (in the sense that the driver knowingly chose to drink and then drive), insurers may invoke these clauses to deny coverage for accidents or damages arising from a DUI incident.
  3. Investigation and Determination: Following a DUI-related accident, insurers will conduct an investigation to determine liability and assess whether coverage applies. If they find that the accident resulted directly from the driver’s impaired state due to alcohol or drugs, they may deny coverage based on policy exclusions related to intentional or criminal acts.
  4. State Regulations: State laws and regulations also play a role. Some states may have specific provisions that allow insurers to deny coverage or cancel policies for drivers convicted of DUI. In states where such actions are permitted, insurers may exercise their right to deny coverage or cancel policies after a DUI conviction.

Each case is evaluated based on its specific circumstances and policy terms, insurers generally have grounds to deny coverage for damages or losses resulting from a DUI-related accident, citing intentional misconduct or policy exclusions related to criminal acts.

Is a DUI Considered “Intentional Conduct” for Car Insurance Purposes?

Is a DUI Considered "Intentional Conduct" for Car Insurance Purposes?

Insurers often argue that driving under the influence constitutes intentional conduct. If accepted, this argument typically allows the insurer to deny coverage for damages resulting from a DUI, including injuries and vehicle damage to parties involved in the accident (under liability coverage) or personal losses such as injuries or vehicle damage (under personal injury protection or collision coverage).

Insurers contend that by choosing to drink, becoming intoxicated, driving while impaired, and knowing the risks, the driver intentionally put themselves in a position to cause an accident.

If you cause an accident while intoxicated, your insurer will investigate before accepting liability for damages. If coverage is denied due to a DUI-related accident, legal assistance may be necessary to contest the insurer’s decision.

Limitations on Car Insurance Coverage After a DUI

When a car insurance policy covers a DUI-related accident, it usually imposes significant limitations, particularly concerning intentional misconduct claims. Intentional misconduct involves deliberately causing harm, as opposed to negligence or carelessness. Therefore, even if coverage extends to a DUI incident, it typically excludes claims and damages associated with intentional misconduct.

  1. Coverage Exclusions: Car insurance policies generally exclude coverage for intentional acts or intentional misconduct. This means if an accident occurs as a result of actions that are deemed intentional—such as driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs—coverage may be denied for damages resulting from these actions.
  2. Legal Distinction: Intentional misconduct differs from negligence, which is typically covered under liability insurance. Negligence involves failing to exercise reasonable care, leading to accidental harm. In contrast, intentional misconduct involves purposeful actions that foreseeably lead to harm.
  3. Policy Interpretation: Insurers interpret DUI incidents as involving intentional misconduct because the driver made a conscious decision to consume alcohol or drugs, knowing it impairs driving ability, and then chose to operate a vehicle. This rationale aligns with policy exclusions that specifically disallow coverage for losses arising from intentional acts.
  4. Claims Handling: If an insurer determines that a DUI-related accident involves intentional misconduct, they may refuse coverage for damages or injuries sustained by the driver, passengers, or third parties. This can include medical expenses, vehicle repair costs, and legal liabilities resulting from the accident.
  5. Legal and Financial Consequences: Drivers involved in DUI incidents may face not only denied insurance claims but also legal repercussions. They could be personally liable for damages, fines, and legal fees associated with the accident, depending on state laws and the severity of the incident.

Can My Car Insurer Cancel My Policy After a DUI?

A DUI conviction makes a driver a high-risk to insurers, often leading them to cancel coverage. While some states prohibit insurers from canceling policies due to DUIs, in states where it’s allowed, cancellation is likely.

Will My Car Insurance Premium Go Up After a DUI?

Yes, your car insurance premium is likely to increase significantly after a DUI (Driving Under the Influence) conviction. Here are the main reasons why:

  1. High-Risk Classification: Insurers consider drivers with DUI convictions to be high-risk because they statistically pose a greater risk of being involved in accidents. As a result, insurance companies adjust premiums to reflect this increased risk.
  2. Policyholder Risk Assessment: Insurance companies use driving records, including any DUI convictions, to assess the risk associated with insuring a driver. A DUI typically signals to insurers that the driver may engage in risky behavior that could lead to future claims.
  3. Underwriting Guidelines: Many insurance companies have specific underwriting guidelines that dictate how much premiums should increase after certain incidents, such as DUI convictions. These guidelines help insurers calculate the new premium based on risk factors.

How Long Will a DUI Stay on My Record?

The duration for which a DUI (Driving Under the Influence) offense stays on your record varies depending on state laws. In general, a DUI conviction typically remains on your driving record for several years, commonly ranging from 5 to 10 years. However, the exact period can differ based on the severity of the offense, any subsequent convictions, and the laws of the state where the offense occurred.

Will a DUI record affect my visa status?

Yes, a DUI (Driving Under the Influence) record can potentially affect your visa status in certain situations. Here are some key points to consider:

  1. Visa Eligibility: Certain types of visas, particularly those that require background checks or involve considerations of moral character or criminal history, may be impacted by a DUI conviction. Examples include visas for employment, study, or immigration purposes.
  2. Admissibility: When applying for a visa to enter a country, including the United States, immigration authorities may consider a DUI conviction as part of the assessment of your admissibility. This is especially true if the offense is recent or if multiple DUIs are involved.
  3. Visa Application Process: Some visa applications require applicants to disclose any criminal history, including DUI convictions. Failing to disclose such information when required can lead to visa denial or other legal consequences.
  4. Travel Restrictions: In some cases, having a DUI conviction may lead to restrictions or additional scrutiny when traveling internationally, depending on the policies of the destination country.
  5. Impact on Existing Visa Holders: If you already hold a visa for a particular country, a DUI conviction may not automatically invalidate your visa. However, it could potentially complicate future visa renewals or extensions, especially if the offense occurred during your stay in that country.

It’s important to check the specific visa requirements and policies of the country you intend to visit or immigrate to. If you have concerns about how a DUI conviction may affect your visa status, consulting with an immigration attorney or seeking guidance from the relevant immigration authorities can provide clarity and guidance tailored to your situation.